Login   Sign Up 



 




  • Oscars 2009 - Predictions, Choices and Comments
    by Zettel at 01:25 on 23 February 2009
    Just in under the wire before the announcements are made.

    I do this every year as a kind of personal aide-memoire. Historically I've been crap at prediction. And my personal preferences, though supported by arguments in reviews are always at root personal. So as a parlour game and for no other reason than to underline that for all its glitz, its over-wrought emotion and just plain up-itself narcissism, Oscar night is irreducibly about marketing, promotion and profit, not art. If the camera lingers too long and lovingly on the Mumbai slum children dragged out of their poverty for a one-off night with the 'stars' being used as a kind of moral blackmail of the Academy voters I may just switch off, throw up, or both. The film industry's track record with real, non-acting-trained kids they have used in films and then left behind is not great. They should turn their cameras on the Mumbai kids from Slumdog Millionaire at next year's Oscars, not this. I have a hunch it would be less than uplifting.

    Haven't seen Milk which has faded fast in UK multi-plexes but without being prejudiced Sean Penn always does a bit too much for me. The Visitor is a beautiful little film far too few people will have seen and Richard Jenkins is superb in it – well worth an Oscar. But despite all the make-up and special effects, the sheer quietly assured way Brad Pitt makes the unreal Benjamin Button both real and affecting is the best male actor performance I have seen this year. I think it will be grotesque sentimentality for Mickey Rourke to win the actor award essentially for playing himself in a movie with a thin cliched narrative simply designed for him.

    Penelope Cruz vs Marisa Tomei is a close call. I'd be happy for it to go either way - though perhaps Marisa has more to do.

    Performance by an actor in a leading role

    Richard Jenkins
    Frank Langella
    Sean Penn
    Brad Pitt
    Mickey Rourke

    Prediction: Mickey Rourke
    Choice: Bradd Pitt

    Performance by an actor in a supporting role

    Josh Brolin
    Robert Downey Jr.
    Philip Seymour Hoffman
    Heath Ledger
    Michael Shannon

    No contest - Heath Ledger. Justifiably not sentimentally but I hope the make-up men and women, is waterproof.

    Performance by an actress in a leading role

    Anne Hathaway
    Angelina Jolie
    Melissa
    Meryl Streep
    Kate Winslet

    Prediction: Not Winslett
    Choice: Kate Winslett

    Performance by an actress in a supporting role

    Amy Adams
    Penélope Cruz
    Viola Davis
    Taraji P. Henson
    Marisa Tomei

    Prediction: Marisa Tomei
    Choice: Marisa Tomei - by a very feisty head.

    Best animated feature film of the year

    Bolt
    Kung Fu Panda
    WALL-E

    WALL-E - no contest

    Achievement in art direction

    Changeling
    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    The Dark Knight
    The Duchess
    Revolutionary Road

    Prediction: Bejamin Button
    Chocie: Benjamin Button

    Achievement in cinematography

    Changeling
    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    The Dark Knight
    The Reader
    Slumdog Millionaire

    Prediction: Slumdog
    Choice: Slumdog

    Achievement in costume design

    Australia
    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    The Duchess
    Milk
    Revolutionary Road

    Prediction: Benjamin Button
    Choice: Benjamin Button
    Comment: The Changeling is a surprising omission here. It is the one it deserved the most.

    Achievement in directing

    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button – David Fincher
    Frost/Nixon - Ron Howard
    Milk - Gus Van Sant
    The Reader - Stephen Daldry
    Slumdog Millionaire - Danny Boyle

    Prediction: David Fincher
    Choice: David Fincher

    Best documentary feature

    The Betrayal
    Encounters at the End of the World
    The Garden
    Man on Wire
    Trouble The Water

    Prediction: Man On Wire
    Choice: Man on Wire
    Comment: This is the one I care about most. Absolutely unique. Inspirational.

    Achievement in film editing

    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    The Dark Knight
    Frost/Nixon
    Milk
    Slumdog Millionaire

    Prediction: Slumdog
    Choice: Slumdog

    Best foreign language film of the year

    The Baader Meinhof Complex
    The Class
    Departures
    Revanche
    Waltz with Bashir

    Prediction: Waltz With Bahir
    Choice: Baader Meinhof Complex
    Comment: Lemon Tree and I’ve Loved You So Long are striking omissions from this list. I would have given I’ve Loved You So Long the Oscar and Kristin Scott Thomas should have been nominated for best lead actress for this superb performance

    Achievement in makeup

    The Curious Case of Benjamin
    The Dark Knight
    Hellboy II

    Prediction: Benjamin Button
    Choice: Benjamin Button.
    Comment: No contest. Breathtaking and totally unobtrusive in style to support the artistic purpose of the movie.

    Achievement in music written for motion pictures (Original score)

    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    Defiance
    Milk
    Slumdog Millionaire
    WALL-E

    Prediction: Slumdog
    Choice: Slumdog
    Comment: Absolutely right. The best thing in the movie and it makes it.

    Achievement in music written for motion pictures (Original song)

    Down to Earth from WALL
    ai Ho from Slumdog Millionaire
    O Saya from Slumdog Millionaire

    No Idea

    Best motion picture of the year

    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (Paramount and Warner Bros.)
    Frost/Nixon
    Milk
    The Reader
    Slumdog Millionaire

    Prediction: Benjamin Button
    Choice: Benjamin Button

    Achievement in sound editing

    The Dark Knight
    Iron Man
    Slumdog Millionaire
    WALL-E
    Wanted

    Prediction: Slumdog
    Choice: Slumdog

    Achievement in sound mixing

    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    The Dark Knight
    Slumdog Millionaire
    WALL-E
    Wanted

    Prediction: WALL-E
    Choice: Slumdog

    Achievement in visual effects

    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    The Dark Knight
    Iron Man

    Prediction: Benjamin Button
    Choice: Benjamin Button
    Comment: No contest. Extraordinary.

    Adapted screenplay

    The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    Doubt
    Frost/Nixon
    The Reader
    Slumdog Millionaire

    Prediction: Benjamin Button
    Choice: The Reader
    Comment: BB is 95% an original screenplay. David Hare did a marvellous job on The Reader

    Original screenplay

    Frozen River
    Happy-Go-Lucky
    In Bruges
    Milk
    WALL-E

    Prediction: In Bruges
    Choice: In Bruges
    Comment: Jonathon and Christopher Nolan should certainly have been nominated here for their brillian script for Dark Knight