Login   Sign Up 



 
Random Read




  • Question for academic types
    by Steerpike`s sister at 20:14 on 08 January 2011
    Again, don't really know where to put this... hope it's OK in this forum.
    What exactly is a 'discussion paper'?
  • Re: Question for academic types
    by alexhazel at 21:58 on 08 January 2011
    I've always understood it to be something intended to invite a debate (i.e. discussion) on a subject. I've never read one, but I imagine they propose various options or raise various issues on a subject which is eventually going to lead to some kind of policy, legislation or administrative procedure.

    Alex
  • Re: Question for academic types
    by Steerpike`s sister at 22:25 on 08 January 2011
    This is in the context of a journal about children's literature (this one: www.write4children.org ) so it can't be about policy. I wonder is it a kind of less formal article?

    <Added>

    maybe you don't have to draw conclusions, but can just invite debate, as you say.
  • Re: Question for academic types
    by alexhazel at 22:34 on 08 January 2011
    I would guess something to stimulate debate about some aspect of children's literature, such as suitable topics or use of language. Although I used to read a lot as a kid, I don't consider myself to be very knowledgeable about children's literature, so I can't offer any other suggestions as to what writers might want to discuss on the topic.
  • Re: Question for academic types
    by EmmaD at 22:39 on 09 January 2011
    Not sure either, TBH. I'd suggest something that sets out and clarifies lots of questions in and around the detail of a subject, in the hope of getting the others in the seminar to add their experience/knowledge/opinions.

    Maybe also something where you're allowed to be tentative - it seems to me that X, but I don't know about Y, which would make a difference...

    Whereas a normal paper is more about method-results-conclusion, and coming to some answers.

    You could always email them and ask what they tend to find works best, as a discussion paper.

    Emma