Login   Sign Up 



 

A Personal Journey to Atheism

by Janeyath 

Posted: 15 September 2013
Word Count: 1369
Summary: This is a short article about my father's journey to becoming an atheist and the influence his had on my life.
Related Works: A Life Lost • 

Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


I am an atheist. It seems like such a simple statement to make and was a relatively easy decision for me. Religion had never been a significant part of my life and my closest friends and family share similar views. I thought about God in the same way that I did about Santa, a mythical being that made an interesting story and sometimes led to gifts and my only experience of worship had been at primary school assemblies and church visits. In my late twenties I began to take the issue of religious belief more seriously and thought about becoming an atheist. This then prompted me to talk to my father, who was open about his atheism and one of the most rational people I know. However, I knew nothing about his early experience of religion and what he had to go through to reject it.

My father grew up in South Manchester with two brothers and two sisters. During his early twenties he gave up a career in the civil service and studied for a mathematics degree at Brunel University, which led to his academic career in computer education. For many years that was all I knew about his background. Like a lot of people, I had never talked to either of my parents at length about their early lives, but, as I matured and began to appreciate them, I wanted to learn more about their lives before sensible careers and children took over. I learnt about how they first met (he was her landlord!) and how they ended up in Reading, where I was brought up. When he began to talk about his childhood, my father revealed that he had been brought up as a catholic and educated at a school run by priests. This was a surprise to me, because I had always assumed that his atheism stemmed from a relatively minimal exposure to religion, similar to my own experience.

His mother was the driving force behind his catholic upbringing and, while his father was not particularly religious, he never spoke out against her beliefs or desires to impose this on their children. This resulted in my father attending the local catholic school and the usual regular rituals and ceremonies at church. Unlike the revelation experience of the average born again Christian, there wasn’t a sudden realisation for him that God did not exist. He had spent many years absolutely believing what he had been taught and it took just as long to question those beliefs and find an alternative to be able to fully reject it.

I already had a lot of respect for my father, but as I learnt about what he went through I realised just how lucky I am. He had to find the strength and resolve to question and stand up to almost everyone around him in positions of authority and trust. The priests at his school, who were supposed to provide teaching and guidance, were the same people who praised a mythical being for creating everything in the world and used the existence of Hell as a threat against anyone who questioned that view or refused to take part in their strange rituals. There was no objectivity to their teaching or opportunity to question it in light of the numerous logical flaws of religion. As his questions went unanswered, my father realised that these were ordinary men who had no influence over whether he would go to Heaven or Hell and used fear and guilt to impose their divine authority. Once this seed had been planted, he then started to question the existence of God. He took more of an interest in science and maths, which provided the basis for the alternative explanation he was seeking. More importantly, he learnt how these theories were developed from the study of real evidence and continually reviewed and adapted as knowledge expanded and new evidence was discovered. He could no longer believe in an invention of the mind which relied on faith to make it real.

This was still not an easy decision. How could he reject what everyone around him believed? Could evolution really explain why humans are moral beings? He had been told over and over again how belief in God was the only way that you could be good. After all, for generations, the imparting of good behaviour had been seen as responsibility of the church. There are many examples throughout history of people who questioned the established religion portrayed as lacking in moral fibre, which then provided the justification for their persecution and, in the worst cases, death. In addition to this, as with many religions, there was a well defined community where he lived centred round the local church, and rejection of this could lead to isolation and alienation.

For this reason, my father didn’t reveal his beliefs to family members and decided that the best solution would be to move away from that community. Education provided the best opportunity to do this and, while working for the civil service, he completed three ‘A’ Levels at night school. He was then able to go to university, because the local education authorities were now required to pay tuition fees and also provide a maintenance grant, without which this would have been out of his reach. I had always known how much my father had valued his university education, because he encouraged his children to seriously consider it, both for the education and experience. I now understood more fully why this meant so much to him. As well as enabling him to move further beyond his upbringing, it released him from an unfulfilling career and allowed him to fully pursue his own interests.

Another aspect about his background, which I had not fully understood, was the development of his political views. During his time at university he was briefly a member of the Communist Party and for a number of years afterwards, a strong supporter of the Labour Party. At university, the group of friends that he connected with, who shared his views about religion, also influenced his political views. This was at a time when Communist societies were much more prevalent than today and a major theme of many of them was the repression of religion. However, it didn’t take him long to realise that he could separate his atheist and political views and, once again, make up his own mind. Unlike the priests who taught him, he knew that he could change and adapt in the face of new evidence. He has continued to do so throughout his life and has been a loyal Conservative voter for the last twenty years!

Now that I know what my father had to go through, I am grateful that he felt able to tell me about his experiences and the reason he became an atheist. This was a very personal and, at times, painful process for him and when he talks about his childhood I am very aware of how this affected him and the resentment he still feels. Despite this, I never felt that he ever tried to “protect” us from religion. My sister and I attended the local Church of England school because both of my parents knew that it was a good school in the right location. His approach was always that we should learn as much as possible about the world, then make up our own minds about what to believe in.

My decision to become atheist was influenced by the beliefs I have developed and also the struggle that others, including my father, have had to reject their religion. I realised that it was not enough for me to simply remain apathetic about religion, when I knew that I did not believe in God and also felt strongly about the problems that religion causes. I’m sure that my father is relieved about the choices I have made, but I also know that, if I had chosen religion it would be something we could talk about rationally and agree to disagree on. After all, when the Jehovah’s Witnesses come to the door he is very happy to invite them in and discuss the error of their ways!






Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



Bunbry at 19:38 on 25 November 2013  Report this post
Hi Jane, this could have been a dry topic or a rant, but it was neither. Rather it was an engaging insigth into you and you father's decisions.

As an aside, there are some parallels between you father and me! I'm from South Manchester originally (the Sale and Altrincham area) and was brought up to believe in God. I king of 'grew out' of it as I thought about how improbable the whole premis of a god was. I then read around the subject a bit which firmed up my non-belief in God.

My daughter went to a Catholic school, because her mother was Catholic and it was a good school and she is a believer.

And I've been Conservative since I was in nappies!

You should post this in IC as we have had similar articles posted to this which have attracted a good deal of interest.

Nick

Janeyath at 19:52 on 25 November 2013  Report this post
Hi Nick

Thank you for the feeback - I will post it to IC. That is really spooky - my dad was born in Altrincham then brought up in Sale!



Manusha at 17:10 on 28 November 2013  Report this post
Hi Jane,

I thought this was a well written article. As you develop your father’s story you have kept closely to the theme which makes it both interesting and easy to follow. It has a good structure and the theme follows naturally and progressively from one paragraph to the next. I'm glad you feel comfortable posting an article about your beliefs in IC. These days it seems easier to remain cautious of speaking of personal beliefs in case someone feels their own beliefs are being challenged. I think that's a shame, because it has led to an atmosphere where any meaningful discussion about differing beliefs tends to be avoided. Such discussions often become competitive rather than being an honest attempt to understand each other's views.

You clearly have the skill to write a biographical article and so I only have a few minor points. I hope they are helpful.

I am an atheist. It seems like such a simple statement to make and was a relatively easy decision for me.

I wonder whether this is playing the conclusion of the article too soon. Perhaps the story of you and your father could be the build up to this conclusion rather than giving it away from the start. Also, beginning in this way tends to imply that the main topic will be about your own journey when it is primarily about your father’s, with its influence on you being the secondary topic. I thought the rest of the paragraph worked well though, and it leads smoothly onto the story about your father.

A teeny weeny point: Catholic is with a capital, as is ‘the Church’.

However, it didn’t take him long to realise that he could separate his atheist and political views and, once again, make up his own mind. Unlike the priests who taught him, he knew that he could change and adapt in the face of new evidence. He has continued to do so throughout his life and has been a loyal Conservative voter for the last twenty years!

I felt that the second sentence disrupted the flow of the point you are making, which is that he decided not to become a Communist but a Conservative instead, and perhaps it could be placed elsewhere in the paragraph. Because‘he could separate his atheist and political views’ seems contradictory (because Communism is an atheistic view), I think it needs to be resolved in the next sentence, i.e. that he became a Conservative. In other words, when we make a point that needs to be qualified, I think it is better to immediately follow with the evidence that supports that point. Whereas, 'Unlike the priests, etc,' seems to be introducing a new point.

As I said, my points are minor because I felt this was well written, and I wish you good luck with wherever you choose to send it.

Regards, Andy

James Graham at 14:49 on 29 November 2013  Report this post
I certainly agree with Andy that this is a well-written, very readable article. There are one or two points (also not major criticisms) that I could add.

As Andy says, your opening few sentences do give the impression that the article will be about your own experience more than that of your father. It would be easy to change the emphasis by saying something about your father almost right away. Something like this:

I am an atheist. It seems like such a simple statement to make and was a relatively easy decision for me. It was very different for my father - though it was not until I was in my late twenties that I talked with him about it and learned his story.


Maybe you could add even more interest by introducing some concrete illustration. Just in one or two places. I’ll explain what I mean. For example, was there a particular moment, incident, or conversation in your father’s early life which was specially significant in determining how his beliefs were formed? There’s an example I can give from my own experience - both my parents were very religious, not Catholic but evangelical (Christian Brethren). They took me to the service every Sunday and I heard the preachers sometimes very luridly describing Hell. (These were lay preachers, with no theological qualifications.) I remember being really scared, quite disturbed; one day I ran out of the hall and my Mum had to come out and comfort me. But as I got older it washed over me a bit more. Then one particular sermon became a turning point. The preacher talked about the sin against the Holy Ghost, and said three things about it: 1. No-one knows, or can ever know, what that sin is; 2. We can never know whether or not we have committed it; 3. Those who commit it cannot be forgiven and will go to Hell. I clearly remember not being scared but thinking, ‘This is rubbish’. (Or thoughts to that effect). It was just so absurd. For me it was uphill from there.

I’m sorry, this has become quite a long story, but it’s just meant to illustrate the point. Maybe there’s something similar in your father’s story? A question he asked a priest, and got an answer that was evasive or dismissive, or seemed absurd? An interaction with a teacher at school?

Another way to illustrate, to make your account more concrete, might be to quote something your father said to you in (more or less) his own words.

I hope this doesn’t begin to seem like a major criticism after all! Really, it isn’t meant to be. Just one or two brief significant illustrations would, I feel, enhance an already very interesting piece.

James.

Janeyath at 15:24 on 29 November 2013  Report this post
Hi Andy and James

Thank you so much for your comments - very helpful and constructive!

James - I have contacted the Humanist in the past but will try the link you have sent (after a few revisions!)

Your experience sounds very similar to my fathers and I agree it would add some more context to the article.

Thanks again.

Manusha at 15:39 on 30 November 2013  Report this post
The preacher talked about the sin against the Holy Ghost, and said three things about it: 1. No-one knows, or can ever know, what that sin is; 2. We can never know whether or not we have committed it; 3. Those who commit it cannot be forgiven and will go to Hell.

How very odd, I've never heard of that. Then again I've not had much experience of how Christianity is taught. According to my understanding of the Vedic conception of the Supreme, it would seem the preacher was speaking total nonsense based on a poor fund of knowledge. It's no wonder people get turned off God if they are asked to believe something so obviously illogical.

Anyhows, I think James makes a good point about adding a quote or illustration from your father's life. It's the same as the showing instead of telling principle in fiction, and can add a certain tangibility to the read.

Wendy Mason at 09:21 on 05 December 2013  Report this post
I agree with the other comments, this is well written and flows well.
My only issue would be the final comment 'After all, when the Jehovah’s Witnesses come to the door he is very happy to invite them in and discuss the error of their ways!' I can see him having an interesting debate but surely he would respect the fact that they may well have their own views that are just different to his? Don't get me wrong, I'm not a JW myself but this did make me feel a little uncomfortable, sorry.

Manusha at 16:46 on 05 December 2013  Report this post
Wendy raises a good point; the final sentence stood out to me as well. I wondered whether to mention it but eventually decided to rationalise it by thinking that perhaps you wanted to end on a lighter note and were deliberately making an ironic statement. I'm curious now whether that was what you meant.

Janeyath at 13:23 on 06 December 2013  Report this post
Hi both,

I put this is because the normal reaction to a JW visit seems to be to politely (or not!) decline to engage with them. My dad likes to have a debate, but would always respect their views and thinks that it is more important to let people make up their own minds.

I don't think he has changed anyone's beliefs yet....



TassieDevil at 17:13 on 10 February 2014  Report this post
Hello Jane,

Very easy to read, engaging story. I felt as though I was a part of this journey and I enjoyed the experience. I have my own views on religion but totally can follow the wisdom of your father

His approach was always that we should learn as much as possible about the world, then make up our own minds about what to believe in.

Like some of the other reviewers, I was a little concerned about the final sentence since, I felt, the rest of the article seemed strangely balanced and not dogmatic.

Good luck with this if you find somewhere to publish it.

Alan




To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .