Elbowsnitch at 09:25 on 21 May 2008
Report this post
|
Hi Jennifer, this is like a flame flaring up and dying. I like the first para in particular - it has real depth of feeling. The rest feels a little contrived to me.
I also very much like humble, subtle and quiet empathy |
|
Is this perhaps a father, being addressed by his daughter?
Frances
| |
tiger_bright at 11:40 on 21 May 2008
Report this post
|
Hi Jennifer, this had the weight and resonance of a sad story. But I wish I'd been able to tease out the specifics - who is the narrator and what is her relationship to the faded presence and the woman who's gone? It felt very personal, perhaps too personal for the average reader to penetrate? I wanted a way in - to connect to these people and really feel their pain - but you let me off the hook of caring, because the anonymity and mystery was too strong. I loved the start to that final paragraph and wondered whether it might not be better to begin the flash with the "what had been" and gradually pull back to the reality of the loss?
Sorry not to be more helpful.
Tiger
| |
V`yonne at 12:30 on 21 May 2008
Report this post
|
That last paragraph is what we all do -we look for that spark. Very sad, Jennifer.
|
|
| |
tusker at 15:02 on 21 May 2008
Report this post
|
Thanks all for your comment. Thanks too, Oonah. Just wrote it for my dog.
Jennifer
| |
|
Forbes at 17:31 on 21 May 2008
Report this post
|
Nice one Jennifer. I can see a sad eyed dog. Hang on I'll need my hankie in a mo!
Cheers
Avis
| |
Prospero at 18:14 on 21 May 2008
Report this post
|
Hi Jennifer
My first thought that this was about a dog, and then when I read Frances' comment I thought I might have got it wrong. So congratulations on transmitting your idea effectively through your writing. Well done.
Best
John
| |
|
|
Forbes at 18:51 on 21 May 2008
Report this post
|
Sorry Jennifer - I forgot your posting in FFII. I was a little flipant back there. But this piece conjured a sad eyed dog very effectively for me. 20 is a great aged. Hope my moggies go on as long.
Avis
| |
tusker at 16:13 on 22 May 2008
Report this post
|
Son-in law says he's going to come back as Jennifer's pet. All our pets, dogs and cats,have lived past 18. All gone now apart from the tortoise, Seamus, and he'll outlive us. No more canines for us.
Jennifer
| |
Prospero at 17:11 on 22 May 2008
Report this post
|
Twenty years! That is a good age. Don't worry, he will be waiting for you in the next life and will probably lick you to death. Furthermore, you will be able to communicate with him telepathically. Be prepared for a few a surprises, they understand a lot more than they can communicate.
Best
John
| |
tusker at 19:01 on 22 May 2008
Report this post
|
Thanks John. Know what you mean. 5 dogs and 2 cats are buried in our garden! They always came in twos's apart from Judy. Our first. No more animals.
Jennifer
| |
Dreamer at 23:29 on 22 May 2008
Report this post
|
Hi Jennifer,
Liked this. Did wonder who 'she' was that the dog missed. Another dog? or an owner?
5 dogs and 2 cats are buried in our garden! |
|
We burried our loving dog in the yard last fall only to have Orion, our 8 month old pup, dig him up two weeks ago...
B.
| |
tusker at 13:27 on 23 May 2008
Report this post
|
Thanks Brian. Yes, 'she' was a dog, a Labrador/Jack Russel cross. She was his eyes.Thank goodness I didn't have that digging up problem. There's a dog in the paper, today, who is 29 years old!
Jennifer
| |
crowspark at 06:43 on 24 May 2008
Report this post
|
An elegiac lament, Jennifer. Wonderful language full of sadness.
I would change the title to identify the subject of your flash.
My cat died recently. I still hear him scratching at the window at night, see him hunting in the garden out of the corner of my eye.
| |
tusker at 07:29 on 24 May 2008
Report this post
|
Thanks for your kind comment. Sorry about your cat. It's horrible. Hate it when people say, 'Get another one.' Pets aren't goods easily disposed of. You'll hear your cat for a while but he's letting you know he's okay, still out there hunting.
Jennifer
| |
|
|
titania177 at 11:10 on 25 May 2008
Report this post
|
Jennifer, a beautiful, sad piece. You conveyed the dog-ness so subtly and gently. So sorry about your dog, this is a beautiful elegy.
|
|
| |
|
Jubbly at 11:52 on 26 May 2008
Report this post
|
while reading this, I had a sensation of the futility but inevitability of human existence, c'est la vie, I guess. Well written.
J
|
|
| |
tusker at 14:27 on 26 May 2008
Report this post
|
Thanks Julie, I suppose, even though it's about my dog, it applies to humans too.
Jennifer
| |