Login   Sign Up 



 

The question of holidays

by joanie 

Posted: 06 January 2008
Word Count: 38


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


Version II
Sometimes home
can serve the purposes
of relaxation,
renewal,
the calm
which too often costs

the Earth.


Version I
Sometimes home
can serve the purposes
of relaxation,
renewal,
the calmness which
too often costs

the Earth.







Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



James Graham at 20:43 on 07 January 2008  Report this post
Joanie, you deliver the goods every time - in the form of short poems that are peepholes we can look through and see much more. Connecting the title (which is essential - I can hardly think of a poem that needs its title more, or whose title makes such a contribution) with the last line, we glimpse the world of holidays that brings with it days and nights going quietly insane in airports while the backlog of flights is slowly sorted out; or one’s first sight of a hotel room the size of a decent broom cupboard, with its view of the rubbish bins and the air-conditioning ducts. Above all, what we see is the cult of travel, the notion that relaxation and renewal have to be purchased from a travel agent, which ‘costs the Earth’ with a capital E, travel being a major contributor to climate change. Anyway, so often the product doesn't do what it says on the label, giving us not relaxation and renewal but stress and more grey hairs.

Something else about this that I notice is your way (that I’m sure I’ve remarked on before) of making a common phrase come to life. ‘Cost the earth’ - how many times must that be said every day? But in the context of the poem, and with your ‘trademark’ space - in which you metaphorically look us in the eye - the phrase is refreshed.

How about

the peace
that too often costs

the Earth.


?

I like the rhythm of that (the peace/the Earth) but maybe ’peace’ isn’t the word you would want.

James.

joanie at 21:45 on 07 January 2008  Report this post
Thank you, James, for your insight and encouragement. I appreciate your response. As for the last lines and your suggestion, I wonder whether a shortened 'calm' might do the trick.
the calm
which too often costs

the Earth.


I'm not sure whether I prefer 'which' or 'that'.

Thanks again!

joanie




James Graham at 21:28 on 08 January 2008  Report this post
Yes, calm...one syllable like 'peace' but with more personal connotations, whereas with 'peace' you can't escape associations of 'world peace' which isn't what your poem is about. Which or that? Take a twopenny piece, throw it up in the air. Heads it's which, tails it's that. Or...'which' is a rather conspicuous sound, whereas 'that' can be nearly inaudible. Perhaps it should be the word in the last three lines that draws least attention to itself.

James.

Ticonderoga at 12:18 on 09 January 2008  Report this post
That's beautiful - James has said it all; version 2 is perfection.

Mike

joanie at 17:41 on 09 January 2008  Report this post
Thank you very much, Mike!

joanie


To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .